Skip to content
Independent money guidance
Clear Money Guide
Start here
Menu

MassMutual vs Vanguard Personal Advisor Fees: What Each Costs in Dollars at $250k, $500k, $1M

Guides › Financial Advisor Fees

Updated September 19, 2026. Quick answer: At $500,000, the published figure for Vanguard Personal Advisor is $1,750 a year, versus $10,350 a year for MassMutual, computed from each firm’s own SEC-filed fee disclosure. See the full side-by-side table below for $250,000, $1 million and $2 million. These are published figures, not quotes. What you would pay depends on the program you choose and any rate you negotiate. Ask both firms for a written quote on the same portfolio before comparing.

What each firm charges, side by side

Account balanceMassMutual (annual fee)Vanguard Personal Advisor (annual fee)
$250,000$5,175$875
$500,000$10,350$1,750
$1,000,000$20,700$3,500
$2,000,000$41,400$7,000

MassMutual discloses a maximum, individually negotiated rate of 2.07% (MML Investors Services, LLC – MMLIS Wealth Management Services Portfolio Solutions Programs Wrap Fee Brochure (Form ADV Part 2A Appendix 1), July 10, 2026); Vanguard Personal Advisor discloses a published gross rate of 0.35% (Vanguard Digital Advisor and Vanguard Personal Advisor Brochure (Form ADV Part 2A), 2026-08-20).

What the fee includes, in each firm’s own words

MassMutual (MML Investors Services, LLC – MMLIS Wealth Management Services Portfolio Solutions Programs Wrap Fee Brochure (Form ADV Part 2A Appendix 1), July 10, 2026): “The Client Fee includes an Execution, Clearing and Custody Fee of 0.06%, a negotiable Advisory Fee up to a maximum of 1.54%, and any applicable fees to Strategists. … Strategist Fees range from 0.05% to 0.47%.”

MMLIS’s Client Fee for the Portfolio Solutions Programs is built from three disclosed components rather than one published schedule: a fixed 0.06% Execution/Clearing/Custody Fee, a negotiable Advisory Fee capped at 1.54% of AUM, and a Strategist Fee ranging 0.05%-0.47% depending on which asset-allocation model/strategist is selected (or 0% if none). Worst-case ceiling = 0.06% + 1.54% + 0.47% = 2.07%, applied uniformly to compute dollar_at as the maximum a client could be charged (250000*0.0207=5175; 500000*0.0207=10350; 1000000*0.0207=20700; 2000000*0.0207=41400). A client’s actual fee would typically be lower depending on the negotiated Advisory Fee and the Strategist Fee of the specific model chosen.

Vanguard Personal Advisor (Vanguard Digital Advisor and Vanguard Personal Advisor Brochure (Form ADV Part 2A), 2026-08-20): “Personal Advisor’s annual gross advisory fee for Vanguard Brokerage Accounts is 0.35% for its all‐index investment options and 0.40% for the exclusive active/index mix. … Enrollments in Personal Advisor require an aggregate $50,000 balance or greater” All-index investment option (any enrolled balance; $50,000 aggregate minimum to enroll): 0.35%; Active/index mix investment option (any enrolled balance): 0.40%.

Flat (non-tiered) gross advisory fee applied to the entire enrolled Vanguard Brokerage Account balance regardless of balance size: 0.35% for the all-index investment option (used here as the base case) or 0.40% if the active/index mix is elected. Dollar figures = balance x 0.0035. This is Vanguard’s disclosed gross fee before the affiliate-revenue credit that Vanguard also applies (which further lowers the net fee actually charged, per the same brochure); the gross rate is used here because it is the stated contractual rate, not an estimate.

How this compares

Our benchmark of published adviser fee schedules puts the weighted median annual cost near $2,000 to $2,500 on $250,000 (the benchmark). At $500,000, MassMutual runs $10,350 a year and Vanguard Personal Advisor runs $1,750 a year: a difference of $8,600 a year at that balance.

Want the full breakdown for either firm on its own? Read the MassMutual fee page or the Vanguard Personal Advisor fee page for the complete tier table and source citations.

Comparing these two against a full move? Read the general mechanics of switching financial advisors, or use a dated termination letter once you decide.

Kapitalwise

Find an advisor to compare.

Explore an advisor introduction. Free to request, with no obligation to hire.

Opens Kapitalwise’s questionnaire in a new tab. Includes contact details and phone verification by text. Expect advisor calls and texts after submitting.

Clear Money Guide may earn a referral payment. Matches aren’t guaranteed, including with firms discussed on this page.

Another option: WiserAdvisor

For U.S. investors with $250,000+ in investable assets.

WiserAdvisor matches qualified consumers with 2 to 3 vetted advisors. Compare their approach and fees.

Compare advisors with WiserAdvisor

Opens their questionnaire in a new tab. Expect calls and texts after submitting.

Who will contact me?

Submitting WiserAdvisor’s form authorizes contact by WiserAdvisor and up to three advisors by phone, text and email. Submitting Kapitalwise’s form shares contact details with advisors; expect calls and texts. Review the chosen service’s consent and privacy terms before submitting. An introduction is not a Clear Money Guide recommendation.

Sources

Methodology. This page was built September 19, 2026, re-pairing figures already archived and independently verified for MassMutual and Vanguard Personal Advisor from each firm’s own SEC-filed disclosure; sources linked above. Nothing here is personalized financial, tax, legal, or investment advice. See our Editorial Policy, Corrections, Affiliate Disclosure, and Disclaimer.

Already with MassMutual and weighing a move? How to leave MassMutual covers what it costs to transfer out.