Clear Money Guide
What this guide covers
A quick view of the questions and evidence developed below.
Comparison tables scroll horizontally on smaller screens.
Updated August 3, 2026. Quick answer: taking a refund of your contributions when you leave public employment gets you your own money back — and in most systems it cancels every year of service you earned, not just the years you were paid for. If you are vested, or might ever return, leaving the money in is usually the better decision.
More on public pension systems, topic by topic: Massachusetts retirement repaying withdrawn deductions and Massachusetts pension after leaving service.
More on public pension systems, topic by topic: Arkansas LOPFI service credit purchase and Kansas KPERS return to work after retirement.
More on public pension systems, topic by topic: Mississippi PERS returning to work and Illinois SERS returning to work.
Refund rules in more systems: Louisiana LSERS retirement decisions, Missouri MPERS retirement decisions, Arkansas LOPFI retirement decisions, Arizona CORP retirement decisions, Oklahoma OPPRS retirement decisions, DC police and firefighters retirement decisions, Iowa MFPRSI retirement decisions, Oklahoma OLERS retirement decisions and Kentucky SPRS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more systems: Kentucky CERS retirement decisions, South Dakota SDRS retirement decisions, Louisiana LASERS retirement decisions, South Carolina PORS retirement decisions, Indiana 1977 Fund retirement decisions, Louisiana Sheriffs’ Pension retirement decisions, Louisiana Parochial Employees’ Retirement decisions, North Dakota TFFR retirement decisions and Oklahoma Firefighters Pension retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more systems: NYC TRS retirement decisions, Michigan MERS retirement decisions, Colorado FPPA retirement decisions, Connecticut MERS retirement decisions and Georgia PSERS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more systems: Norfolk County Retirement System decisions, Bristol County Retirement System decisions and Cambridge Retirement System decisions.
Refund rules in more systems: Ohio Highway Patrol Retirement System decisions, Maryland LEOPS retirement decisions, Middlesex County Retirement System decisions, Worcester Regional Retirement System decisions and Louisiana Firefighters Retirement System decisions.
Refund rules in more systems: Minnesota PERA Police and Fire retirement decisions, Washington LEOFF retirement decisions, Louisiana MPERS retirement decisions, San Antonio Fire and Police pension decisions, Austin Police Retirement System decisions and Pennsylvania PMRS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more city systems: LAFPP retirement decisions, Houston firefighters retirement decisions, Kansas City school retirement decisions, Tampa fire and police pension decisions and Atlanta firefighters pension decisions.
Refund rules in more city systems: Portland FPDR retirement decisions, Wichita Employees’ Retirement System decisions, Detroit police and fire retirement decisions, Baltimore fire and police retirement decisions and Jacksonville police and fire pension decisions.
Refund rules in more city and county systems: Cincinnati Retirement System decisions, St. Louis Employees Retirement System decisions, Kansas City employees retirement decisions, Metro Nashville pension decisions, Memphis city retirement decisions and Montgomery County Maryland retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more city and county systems: Oklahoma City ERS retirement decisions, Tampa general employees retirement decisions, Tulare County TCERA retirement decisions, StanCERA retirement decisions, SJCERA retirement decisions, SBCERS retirement decisions and Imperial County retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more city, county and fund systems: Chicago police PABF retirement decisions, Chicago firefighters FABF retirement decisions, Chicago Laborers’ Fund retirement decisions, Fort Worth ERF retirement decisions, Atlanta general employees pension decisions, Jacksonville general employees pension decisions, Miami FIPO retirement decisions and Sonoma County SCERA retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more city and county systems: San Francisco SFERS retirement decisions, Chicago teachers CTPF retirement decisions, Milwaukee ERS retirement decisions, Fairfax County ERS retirement decisions, VCERA retirement decisions, KCERA retirement decisions and Boston Retirement System decisions.
Refund rules in more city and county systems: Houston HPOPS retirement decisions, Philadelphia pension retirement decisions, Detroit GRS retirement decisions, Baltimore ERS retirement decisions, Sacramento SCERS retirement decisions, CCCERA retirement decisions, FCERA retirement decisions and SamCERA retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more city and county systems: Phoenix COPERS retirement decisions, Austin COAERS retirement decisions, Dallas ERF retirement decisions, Dallas DPFP retirement decisions, Chicago MEABF retirement decisions, SBCERA retirement decisions and ACERA retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more city and county systems: SDCERS retirement decisions, SDCERA retirement decisions, Denver DERP retirement decisions, Seattle SCERS retirement decisions and Houston HMEPS retirement decisions.
Estimate a Wisconsin Retirement System benefit from age, service and final average earnings: WRS retirement calculator.
Estimate a CalSTRS benefit from age, service credit and final compensation: CalSTRS retirement calculator.
Estimate a PSERS annuity from class, service and final average salary: PSERS retirement calculator.
Refund rules in five more public systems: Mississippi PERS retirement decisions, Ohio Police & Fire retirement decisions, Wyoming Retirement System decisions, Illinois SERS retirement decisions and Nebraska NPERS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more public systems: Montana TRS retirement decisions, Delaware state pension retirement decisions, Vermont VSERS and VSTRS retirement decisions and New Jersey PFRS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more public systems: Hawaii ERS retirement decisions, Michigan MPSERS retirement decisions, Rhode Island ERSRI retirement decisions, Massachusetts state retirement decisions and North Carolina LGERS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more public systems: West Virginia PERS and TRS retirement decisions, Alaska PERS and TRS retirement decisions, NDPERS retirement decisions, Montana PERS retirement decisions and MainePERS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in more public systems: SERS of Ohio retirement decisions, OCERS retirement decisions, LACERS retirement decisions and NHRS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in five more public systems: PERSI retirement decisions, SURS retirement decisions, Arkansas ATRS retirement decisions, ERS Georgia retirement decisions and PSPRS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in five more public systems: KPERS retirement decisions, Minnesota MSRS retirement decisions, Utah Retirement Systems retirement decisions, UCRP retirement decisions and Arkansas APERS retirement decisions.
Refund rules in five more public systems: TCDRS retirement decisions, ERS of Texas retirement decisions, Pennsylvania SERS retirement decisions, Nevada PERS retirement decisions and LACERA retirement decisions.
What a refund actually returns
A refund pays out your contributions. It does not pay out the employer’s contributions, which in most systems are the larger share and stay with the plan. So the headline number is smaller than the amount that was going in on your behalf, often by a lot.
Interest is where systems differ sharply, and it is not always favourable:
| System | What a refund pays | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| STRS Ohio | member contributions, per statute | the refund “cancels the member’s total service credit” — all of it, not just the refunded period (ORC 3307.56(C)) |
| TRS Illinois | contributions with no interest | years of inflation borne entirely by you |
The Ohio provision is the one that catches people. It is easy to assume a refund unwinds the years you are paid for and leaves the rest intact. It does not. A member with fifteen years who refunds a short early period can find the whole fifteen cancelled, and with it any path to a vested benefit.
Coordinate this with the rest of your retirement plan
A pension election is usually a one-time choice you cannot revisit, and an adviser can weigh it against your other income, your spouse’s position and how long the money has to last, though that does not replace the numbers in your own plan documents.
Before you start, what actually happens. The form is run by Kapitalwise, our advisor-matching partner. Kapitalwise sends your details to advisers who pay for the introduction, so expect calls and texts. Clear Money Guide is paid when you submit the form, whether or not you ever hire anyone. This is free to you and there is no obligation to hire anyone.
The Kapitalwise form opens here. You stay on this page.
What happens when you press the button
It asks about nine questions (age, investable assets, location), then your name, email and phone number, and verifies the phone by text. Nothing loads and nothing reaches Kapitalwise until you press the button. Submitting the form does not guarantee an adviser or a match. This matching form is not tax or legal advice.
The decision, in the order it should be made
- Are you vested? If yes, a refund trades a lifetime benefit for a cash sum that excludes the employer’s money. That trade is rarely good, and it is irreversible in the systems that cancel service.
- Might you ever return to covered employment? Public-sector careers are interrupted more often than people expect. Reinstating cancelled service later normally means buying it back at actuarial cost — far more than the refund paid you.
- Do you need the money now? A genuine need is a genuine reason. But compare it against what the refund costs you, not against zero.
The tax point people miss
A refund paid directly to you is generally taxable income, and if you are under the relevant age it may carry an early-distribution penalty as well. Rolling it to an IRA instead preserves the tax deferral. The refund cheque is not the amount you keep. Your own system’s refund paperwork states its withholding and rollover treatment, and that is the document to read rather than a general rule.
When a refund is the right call
It usually is when you are well short of vesting, have left the sector for good, and the sum is small enough that leaving it sitting for decades against an uncertain future benefit serves no one. In that case the money is genuinely yours and there is no lifetime benefit being given up.
What makes it a bad decision is doing it while vested, or while there is any real chance of returning — and the systems that cancel all service make that mistake permanent.
Related: buying service credit back · what buying it back would cost.
General information drawn from IRS, Medicare, HUD and state statute and regulation, not legal, tax or financial advice. Continuing-care law is state law and differs materially between states; every figure here is year-labelled and every source named. Powers of attorney, guardianship and trusts are governed by STATE law and differ change, and interest rates published by the IRS change every month – never rely on a rate quoted on any page, including this one. We are not a law firm or a tax adviser, and this is not legal or tax advice.